With the 2025 season winding down, here's a comprehensive look at the entire list of Silver Slugger winners in Mets history. Gary Carter - 1986 - .255/.337/.439 24 homers 105 RBI 115 OPS+The second Silver Slugger award Carter would win in a Mets uniform, and the final of the five he'd win in his career. However, his 2000 season was likely better offensively than his 1999 campaign, which was the only time he'd take home Silver Slugger honors. Reyes would go on to win a batting title in 2011, but 2006 was the only Silver Slugger honor he'd win during his career. However, the 2022 honor was well-deserved, and McNeil is the only Met in history to take home a Silver Slugger without hitting double-digit home runs.