While the cost of car insurance is soaring across the board, some drivers are paying more for reasons you may not expect. However, FOX 13 found Mauser got a break on his car insurance, while Williams took a hit-- $92 a month for Mauser, versus $160 a month for Williams. READ: Travel Tuesday 2024: Here's when it is and how to snag the best dealsLike many drivers, Williams has something working against him. FOX 13 met with Williams and Mauser 10 years ago and found Williams is still paying more for car insurance. Williams pays more per month for car insurance than Mauser who has a worse driving record.