From her breakout role as April Ludgate on Parks and Recreation to her recent plaudits for Emily the Criminal and The White Lotus, Plaza has built a career out of zigging where anyone else would zag, giving even her smaller roles an unexpected quality that makes them instantly memorable. Plaza’s Riley – an ex of Harper’s who went through a similarly difficult situation – becomes a needed sounding board and shoulder, and Plaza brings such warmth and wisdom to the character that there was quite an outcry when Abby didn’t wind up with Riley by the time the film was over.