While Theo didn’t reach the Season 40 final, he seemingly landed something more valuable: the love and affection of his castmate, Olivia Kaiser. Since appearing on the show, Theo and Olivia have continued to explore their relationship, with Theo deciding to visit Olivia in the United States. They last appeared on MTV’s The Challenge Season 40 as part of the Era 4 team, and their showmance was one of several spotlighted. Theo was on Love Island UK 3 while Olivia appeared in Love Island USA 3 and won the season with now-ex Korey Gandy. The Challenge Season 41 is TBA on MTV.