Which New York lake do you think is prettiest in the state of New York? From the Adirondacks ro the Finger Lakes spots like Lake George, Lake Placid, Cayuga Lake, and so many others are worthy of the title of 'New York's Prettiest Lake.' Central New York Lake Is The Prettiest In the StateKeuka Lake in the Finger Lakes - fall shot across blue lake pawtraitd loading... Fun Keuka Lake FactsVineyard on Keuka Lake, New York, with autumn trees in the background jimfeng loading... You can find a full Finger Lakes winery guide from Visit Finger Lakes here.