However, some of the best contributions in the Blue Jays' lineup comes from four players who are in the top ten in batting average in the American League. Without these players, the story of the 2025 Toronto Blue Jays tells a different tale when it's all said and done. Blue Jays could have four of the AL's top ten batting average leaders in their playoff lineupAL and NL Batting Title pic.twitter.com/sUTcUivbp6 — Thomas Nestico (@TJStats) September 15, 2025All stated batting averages below are as of the conclusion of September 16's game. While Bichette's regular-season-ending injury comes at a terrible time, he'll still be remembered as a big contributing factor for the Blue Jays' eventual playoff birth. Finding success in the middle of the order, the young catcher remains a key piece for the Blue Jays' lineup to keep their World Series aspirations alive.