Later that day, Braff posted a photo of Pugh getting her hair and makeup done to his Instagram Story with the caption, "Holy shit!" For Pugh's 26th birthday on January 3, Braff posted a candid Instagram Story tribute offering a rare look into their relationship and all he thinks of her. Months after their breakup, Braff signaled he and Pugh were still on good terms when he posted a tribute to his ex on his Instagram Story to mark her 27th birthday on January 3.