CSAA Insurance Group, which underwrites AAA car insurance in the largest number of states, charges slightly lower full coverage car insurance rates on average than Allstate. Driver type CSAA liability-only monthly premium CSAA full coverage monthly premium Clean driving record $157 $231 Speeding ticket on driving record $215 $317 At-fault accident on driving record $240 $353 DUI on driving record $225 $331 Teen driver $475 $699 Senior driver (60s) $99 $145 Senior driver (70s) $141 $207 Data sourced from Insurify Driver type Allstate liability-only monthly premium Allstate full coverage monthly premium Clean driving record $91 $158 Speeding ticket on driving record $97 $196 At-fault accident on driving record $99 $200 DUI on driving record $104 $210 Teen driver $152 $308 Senior driver…