I'd recommend AAA car insurance if you live in an eligible state and want to work with a regional company, especially if you're already an AAA member. AAA might not necessarily have the cheapest rates, but it offers a fair deal more discounts than many of its competitors to help you save money on car insurance, including a discount for being a long-time AAA member. AAA and GEICO provide similar car insurance discounts, but you're likely to qualify for lower car insurance rates with GEICO.