Driver type GEICO liability-only monthly premium GEICO full-coverage monthly premium Clean driving record $79 $144 Speeding ticket on driving record $108 $197 At-fault accident on driving record $105 $191 DUI on driving record $113 $206 Teen driver $141 $258 Senior driver (60s) $57 $104 Senior driver (70s) $55 $101 Data sourced from Insurify GEICO's vast array of car insurance discounts sets it apart from many other insurers, including State Farm, which is known for offering many options to save on car insurance. How to cancel GEICO car insurance If you're a current GEICO customer but you're looking to change that, you can follow these steps to cancel GEICO car insurance: Call customer service and tell them you want to cancel your policy.