Between the bustling Hamptons and the increasingly popular North Fork sits Shelter Island, a perfect combination of the two. No longer as secluded or secret as it once was, Shelter Island remains the Hamptons’ quiet cousin, partially due to its lack of accessibility—you have to take a ferry to get on and off the island. For an island you can drive across in less than 30 minutes, there’s an impressive diversity of accommodations and activities. For those looking to experience a taste of the “out East” without the crowds (and prices) of the Hamptons, Shelter Island is a chic oasis free of lines. Where to StayPhoto: Courtesy of The Boathouse by Boutique HomesWithin walking distance of the North Ferry, The Boathouse is the ultimate home base for anyone wishing to cosplay as a Shelter Island homeowner for the weekend.