Other menu items also get plenty of attention, including the waffle fries, but not every well-liked menu mainstay stuck around forever. Chick-fil-A's lemon meringue pie, which it simply called a lemon pie, technically existed before Chick-fil-A itself. Made from scratch with whole ingredients, it joined the debut Chick-fil-A menu in 1967 and stayed there for decades. Customers were dismayed when Chick-fil-A discontinued the lemon pie in 2012 to make room for a more modernized menu. There is, however, one place where you can still have this particular lemon pie served to you.