YouTube, in the spring of 2005, was a dating service. RealPlayer had been streaming clips since the late 1990s; Vimeo launched in November 2004, five months before YouTube’s domain was even registered; Google Video was already in beta. What the record shows about the elephant clipThe neat version of the origin story — dating site fails, Karim films elephants, YouTube is born — is largely true, but it flattens the timeline. What survived into the presentYouTube today is a different piece of infrastructure from the Flash-based clip site of 2005. The dating site never had a second video.