Closing arguments have concluded and the trial of Luciano Frattolin is headed to the hands of the jury. ELIZABETHTOWN, N.Y. (WNYT)- Closing arguments have ended in Luciano Frattolin’s murder trial and the case is expected to go to the jury Monday, August 10. Related: Frattolin murder trial: Closing arguments begin in Essex Co. CourtClosing arguments lasted about two and a half hours in Essex County Court Monday morning. The defense told jurors police moved too quickly to decide Frattolin was responsible for his daughter, Melina’s, murder. Defense lawyers also argued police dismissed the possibility that kidnappers were responsible for Melina’s abduction and murder too quickly.