One day in middle school, I emerged from my bedroom with a fresh DIY pedicure. “It looks like you have a fungus,” she said, unknowingly inhabiting my brain for two decades, leading me to opt exclusively for classic pedicure colors. Creamy whites, vivid reds, and, of course, clean French tips—my toenails aren’t exactly a fashion statement, but they always flatter whatever I’m wearing, no matter the season. This makes the decision process extremely quick and easy, so I’m never wavering at all the options, entirely unsure what to pick. Try one of these simple colors that go with everything.