ESPN's College GameDay brought more than football excitement to Tuscaloosa on Saturday. He challenged Herbstreit to throw a football through the uprights from 33 yards away. Herbstreit asked, “No warmup?” McAfee simply replied, “No.” But for the 56-year-old College GameDay analyst, this was just another Saturday. That's College GameDay magic. In a matter of moments, one student's life can change forever due to a missed chance and a clutch throw.