& Juliet asks: what would happen next if Juliet didn’t end it all over Romeo? This Is Us star Chrissy Metz will make her Broadway debut in & Juliet as Angélique from June 18 through September 13, 2026. Joey Fatone will play Lance for the following dates: August 4-15 and September 1-13. Paolo Szot will play Lance from August 18-30. Social media star Anthony Gargiula will make his Broadway debut in & Juliet for a three-month engagement from September 15-December 6.