25 Footballers Who Have Been Overrated Over the Years1. Neymar (Brazil)Despite his undeniable talent, Neymar has long been criticized for his inconsistent performances in crucial matches and his frequent injuries. Critics believe he was overhyped early in his career, unable to sustain the same level of excellence. Jack Wilshere (England)Once considered one of England’s brightest prospects, Wilshere’s injuries and inconsistent form led many to believe he was overrated relative to his early promise. El-Hadji Diouf (Senegal)Known more for controversy than consistent performance, Diouf’s reputation for overrated playing was cemented by his unpredictable displays.