Under a plea agreement accepted by the court, Eslick is guaranteed probation, though the judge retains discretion to order up to one year of jail time. The incident occurred during a Delta Tau Delta fraternity initiation game in Flagstaff. A former fraternity member pleaded guilty on Aug. 10 to felony hazing following the fatal alcohol poisoning of an 18-year-old during a fraternity initiation game in Flagstaff. According to investigators, Martinez had attended a Delta Tau Delta fraternity rush event Friday night, where several people, including the victim, were reportedly drinking alcohol. Police arrested three members of the fraternity's executive board: new member educator Carter Eslick, 20; Vice President Ryan Creech, 20; and Treasurer Riley Cass, 20.