Duff, on tour behind her fantastic new album Luck … or Something, unearthed the fan favorite, performing it for the first time since 2006. She Brings Out Surprise GuestsAt every show on tour, Duff reaches into a mini fridge onstage and pulls out a beverage — typically orange wine or an Aperol Spritz. “Well, Hil, we’ve gotten to put a hole in the bottle in your neck of the woods,” she told Duff. That same evening, Duff told the crowd about a scare her family had earlier that day. “To lean on the old songs and celebrate and champion how we first met, it’s a dream,” Duff told MSG.