The debate surrounding transgender athletes in women’s sports has never completely disappeared, but it has found its way back into the center of the sports conversation this summer. Coco Gauff became one of the latest stars to weigh in this week, offering a considerably more nuanced response than some of the voices that have dominated the conversation. She called the increasingly aggressive rhetoric surrounding transgender people “sickening” and argued that framing transgender women as dangers inside women’s locker rooms perpetuates harmful stereotypes. That brings the conversation to Coco Gauff, whose comments this week offered something different from either side’s more absolute arguments. What’s becoming increasingly clear is that there isn’t one unified position among women athletes — or even among people who broadly agree on protecting women’s sports.