Classico Tomato PiesYoutube screengrab Youtube screengrabClassico Tomato Pies is located at 358 Princeton Hightstown Rd in West Windsor Township, NJ. Youtube screengrab Youtube screengrabWhat's the difference between tomato pie and pizza pie? "With tomato pies, the cheese comes first, then the filling, then the tomato sauce topping. Pizza pies do it the other way around," says Steve Cabrera, 'pizza master' and co-owner of Classico. Youtube screengrab Youtube screengrabAfter his first bite Portnoy could tell this would be a good review.