The reviews are in, and while many critics have trouble getting past the “creepy” concept, they’re generally in agreement that the leads — Barbaro in particular — are enjoyable to watch. Guy Lodge of Variety says Monica Barbaro and Callum Turner are too hot for this movie, and the movie is “too creepy to be cute,” with its vibes of The Handmaid’s Tale. And yet its charming leads, Monica Barbaro and Callum Turner, do enough to keep One Night Only pleasantly watchable. If you can get past that premise, Will Gluck allows you to settle in for a silly, delightful romantic comedy. Monica Barbaro and Callum Turner do their best, but too many critics struggled with the oppressive, dystopian premise to fully lose yourself in any of the romance.