Some might argue that Jonathan Taylor is already the best running back in Indianapolis Colts history, but statistically that isn't completely true. Currently, Taylor trails Edgerrin James in rushing yards and total yards. Total yards is where Taylor has the most ground to gain, literally, though his new extension should give him that. But since Jonathan Taylor is with the Indianapolis Colts through 2028, he should easily surpass Edgerrin James in rushing yards and total yards. At the pace he has set, Taylor would end 2028 with 104 career rushing touchdowns and 114 total touchdowns, surpassing Moore.