Four New York Cities Made the ListFour cities in New York were among those that surprised new residents the most. They were Buffalo, Rochester, New York City, and Yonkers. New York City Brings the Biggest ShockNew York City ranked highest among the four New York cities. Older Homes Surprise Many MoversPeople who moved to Buffalo and Rochester said they liked the lower home prices but they were surprised by how old the homes are. Yonkers Offers a Mix of City and SuburbsMany people move to Yonkers because it is close to New York City.