Key Points Key Points Aniya Harvey switched from original partner KC Chandler to connect with Carl Schmidt at Casa Amor but ultimately chose to stick with KC, then Carl was voted back into the Villa, and the couple finished second place on Love Island USA’s recent season. Iwill say it: Aniya Harvey and Carl Schmidt had one of the best storylines on the most recent season of Love Island USA. Fans were actively rooting for them once Aniya connected with Carl at Casa Amor after being committed to her original match, KC Chandler. But when KC returned from Casa and chose Tierra “I’m Titi” Davis, he left Aniya brokenhearted, single, and vulnerable…until fans voted for Carl to return to the Villa for another shot at love. As a reminder, Aniya and Carl appeared on Watch What Happens Live last week alongside Trinity and Bryce, where they were straight-up asked about their post–Love Island status.