Meeting every week, the group reviewed major on-field refereeing decisions, with the outcome of each discussion published on the Scottish FA’s website. Despite the attention those verdicts attracted, the panel was never given any formal powers. After a VAR review, Martin O’Neill’s side were awarded a penalty for handball. When the Key Match Incident Review Panel later voted 2-1 against the VAR intervention, social media quickly filled with claims that Celtic’s eventual league triumph had somehow been exposed. Speaking in November last year, he said it had “no value” and claimed referees paid little attention to either its discussions or its conclusions.