A majority now believes Jews can largely handle antisemitism on their own, and nearly one-third no longer considers Holocaust denial to be antisemitic. The survey’s finding that 55% of Americans now believe Jews can handle antisemitism on their own is especially revealing. Yet when the target is Jews, many Americans increasingly regard antisemitism as a Jewish problem rather than an American one. They drift, one rationalization at a time, until the unacceptable becomes merely unfortunate and the unfortunate becomes ordinary. And when hatred no longer shocks us, it has already won.