6 Police arrested Jesse Butler after he was accused of sexual assaulting two girls. Stillwater Police Department6 Jesse Butler, a Stillwater teen convicted of rape, is a free man after completing the terms of his probation, a Payne County judge ruled on August 3. 6 One of Jesse Butler’s victims is pictured in the hospital. Rachel Bussett, who represented the family of one of Butler’s victims, was left disappointed by the outcome – and also scolded Chance. 6 Demonstrators gather to protest the Jesse Butler case outcome outside Payne County Courthouse in Stillwater, Okla., on Wednesday, Nov. 5, 2025.