For his part, Owen had no intention to be spending his night out. Alas, his longtime girlfriend (Maya Hawke) waited until this very evening to announce she wants to explore alternatives around town. While Gluck’s previous Anyone But You benefitted commercially from the current star wattage of Glen Powell and Sydney Sweeney, Barbaro and Turner’s romance is breezier and far more natural. Allie and Owen’s curiosity feel genuine, but it never quite achieves the grand romantic rush of its aspirations or influences. One Night Only is certainly unafraid of playing the hits, sometimes literally, but there’s something cozy about its half-forgotten familiarity.