Sidney Starr remains jailed in protected housing as new police details reveal an unexpected discovery during her hotel arrest. Sidney Starr’s arrest took a bizarre turn when an open condom reportedly tumbled from her pocket as officers searched her. A new arrest update says officers removed Starr’s cellphone during a search before the unexpected item appeared. “When they removed her cell phone, they said ‘an open condom fell from the same pocket,’ while another condom was also found,” police records reportedly state. Arrest warrants allege she performed oral sex on a boy inside the hotel and later described the contact as consensual to investigators.