The digital tribute was shared on July 16, four days shy of what would've been the West Side Story star's 88th birthday. Investigative book writer Marti Rulli scoffed at the Instagram post, accusing Wagner of stonewalling Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department (LASD) homicide investigators, and suspects the aging hunk is preparing to meet his maker. "Is he trying to show they were madly in love? She was sick of his drinking, and she didn't want to put up with his jealousy. He killed her, and I think he's going to hell."