All the little goodies mixed in just make this type of ice cream feel like, well, more of a treat. I got a hold of the mysterious Jeni’s black ice cream to try it for myself. We Tried It Jeni's Opaque Ice CreamWhat is the Jeni’s black ice cream? How did the Jeni’s black ice cream taste? Final ThoughtsThis is quite possibly the best ice cream I’ve ever eaten—and I eat a lot of ice cream.