It's worth reiterating that the 2026 NFL rookie class has little fanfare outside No. 1 overall pick Fernando Mendoza and No. The 2025 class, however, is littered with undervalued options that have proven to be successful at the NFL level. 6 overall pick in last year's class who performed only marginally better (1,321 yards) in three more games. Collectors will have a hard time finding value in the 2026 rookie class, but there's plenty of meat on the bones when it comes to the 2025 group.