None
NO
Comment on The World Record for the Shortest Math Article: 2 Words by bub
[]
Comments for Open Culture
In 2004, John Conway and Alexander Soifer, both working on mathematics at Princeton University, submitted to the American Mathematical Monthly what they believed was “a new world record in the number of words in a [math] paper.”
Soifer explains: “On April 28, 2004 … I submitted our paper that included just two words, ‘n2 + 2 can’ and our two drawings.
The story then continues: “The American Mathematical Monthly was surprised, and did not know what to do about our new world record of a 2‑word article.
Your article, however, is a bit too short to be a good Monthly article… A line or two of explanation would really help.
Accordingly, I replied [to] The Monthly the same day”:I respectfully disagree that a short paper in general—and this paper in particular—merely due to its size must be “a bit too short to be a good Monthly article.”