The plot involves a mysterious ice cream man whose treats turn the idyllic suburban town's children into murder machines. After the hundredth time, it’s obvious that Ice Cream Man has only one gag. Or in the case of Ice Cream Man, they barely have a story at all. Tyler Nichols of JoBlo says Ice Cream Man is the epitome of “turn your brain off” cinema. Overall, Ice Cream Man holds a 26% Rotten Tomatoes score, but will it go down as one of the worst horror movies of the year?