Ari Millen in "Ice Cream Man." The Horror Section/Valerie FloresIce Cream Man, the latest horror thriller from director Eli Roth, has many Rotten Tomatoes critics screaming bloody murder. He also turns up on camera as well, in films like Quentin Tarantino’s Inglorious Basterds, Rock of Ages and now, in Ice Cream Man. As of the publication of this article, Ice Cream Man has earned a 31% “rotten” critics’ score on RT’s Tomatometer based on 39 reviews. Thanksgiving used inventive variations on its gimmick to build toward its sicko smorgasbord finale, an escalation of gnarly ingenuity that Ice Cream Man lacks.”