Picking out an ice cream flavor at the grocery store can be an overwhelming experience. Some might say that the best idea is to gravitate toward the expensive brands, figuring high cost means high quality, but this isn't necessarily the case. We found that even though Häagen Dazs is a premium, delicious, and surprisingly American brand of ice cream (if not a bit pricey), one Kroger dupe put it to shame: Private Selection ice cream. Kroger sells 14-ounce containers of Häagen-Dazs ice cream for at least $6 in some locations. Meanwhile, its Private Selection line of ice cream is priced at $3.99 for 16 ounces of product.