A few days ago, the singer—born Tucker Harrington Pillsbury—performed his still-unreleased song “Love I You” at a secret live show at Thalia Hall in Chicago. Videos of course leaked, and thank goodness, because were it not for them, we wouldn’t know that Johnson makes the sexiest, most romantic cameo in the track. In the song's bridge, Johnson leaves a voicemail for Pillsbury saying, “Tucker, it’s me. I know you’re on stage right now, but I just… I can’t stop thinking about what you said. In case you missed it, Pillsbury and Johnson began dating around December 2025, and have since been spotted on dates around the world.