He and a broad range of religious and secular supporters failed to get SCOTUS to review the case in 2023. "In mandatory trainings, employees will not be required to personally affirm statements about gender identity that violate their sincerely-held religious beliefs," it says. Michigan's law remained blocked, and the case put on hold as SCOTUS considered Kaley Chiles' challenge to Colorado's law. Judge Cartwright's resurrection of the Washington lawsuit is only documented in a July 30 "minute entry" following a hearing on counselor Tingley's motion to reopen. If Cartwright disagrees, she should limit Tingley's relief to the exact claim in Chiles, an "as-applied free speech challenge," Brown said.