Instead, a demolition application for the roughly 300-year-old structure at 453 Montauk Highway has been withdrawn, giving town officials, preservation advocates and the property’s new owner an opportunity to explore alternatives for the historic landmark. “The house served as a tavern for a period of time and then later as a private home for prominent area residents,” Kesnig said. The property, located within the East Moriches Historic District, recently became the subject of an application before Brookhaven’s Historic District Advisory Committee seeking permission to demolish the historic residence. “While I haven’t spoken to him personally, I believe the fact that he withdrew the demolition application indicates his willingness to discuss alternative options.” Top: Public records show the Osborn property changed hands in December 2025.