Why did the Supreme Court disagree with the CAT and high court? Importance of Work Report in scientist promotionsThe Supreme Court also emphasised that the Work Report carries significant importance in assessing scientists. It observed that the weight to be attached to a Work Report depends on the nature of the research undertaken. The question of how much weight should be given to each factor is best left to the Assessment Committee. Accordingly, the Supreme Court set aside the orders passed by the CAT and the Karnataka High Court.