The cast of Love Island USA (specifically Trinity, Bryce, Aniya, and Carl) joined Andy Cohen on Watch What Happens Live last night, and we have a LOT to discuss. Starting with the cast’s defense of Melanie and Sincere’s relationship—despite many fans rooting for Melanie to dump him. Aniya was asked directly why she was willing to root for Sincere despite his treatment of Melanie, saying “I feel like being in the Villa, you guys only see an hour of everything that was happening. I’m still winning her family over, I’m still winning Melanie over. Reminder: The Love Island USA reunion drops next month on August 31, so we’ll get a chance to hear from Melanie and Sincere on where things stand then!