That's precisely what you get when you enjoy your favorite frozen treat at Nicholas Creamery. It was only a short time later in August 2018 that the second location in Fair Haven opened, where its popularity continued much like it did in its first location (keep scrolling to check out the video from our visit to the Fair Haven location). Mike Brant TSM Mike Brant TSMSupporting the local schoolsOne thing I always appreciated about Nicholas Creamery is its commitment to the local schools. Mike Brant TSM Mike Brant TSMSpeaking of votingNicholas Creamery is hoping they can count on your vote to name them the best ice cream at the Jersey Shore. Nicholas Creamery has locations in Atlantic Highlands, Fair Haven, Tinton Falls, Long Branch, Middletown, Wall, and North Brunswick.