Finding the best pizza in America is a tall order. A task of this caliber requires a coalition, and every year the international guide 50 Top Pizza sends out its armada of anonymous inspectors to scour the world with a fine tooth comb for the very best pizza. For the acclaimed and unknown, the strictly traditional and gleefully experimental, below is the 2026 list of the best pizza in America, according to the pros at 50 Top Pizza. Una PizzaUna Pizza NapoletanaLearning the lore behind this Lower East Side pizza spot will only deepen your appreciation for their meticulously crafted pies even further. Having taken home the top spot on the 50 Top Pizza list for three years, Una Pizza Napoletana defends its aptonym well.