Jessi Draper dropped a bombshell on Stassi Schroeder when she claimed that Scheana Shay tried to get cast on The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives. Production has picked back up on season 5 of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives — but is every cast member returning? Viewers were originally introduced to The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives cast after the show premiered on Hulu in 2024. “I would be more surprised if she didn’t try to get on Secret Lives of Mormon Wives.” Related: ‘Secret Lives of Mormon Wives’ Then vs. Now: How Cast Looked Pre-Hulu Show The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives fans have watched the cast change on and off screen before the series even debuted.