Andy Cohen and the cast at the In The City Season 1 Reunion. RELATED: We Asked, You Voted, & the In The City Cast Answered *This* QuestionDanielle, meanwhile, told her boyfriend Eoin, "See, this goes fast, right?" The cast of In the City rehashes the season with Andy during the reunion in New York City. Photo: BravoThat's a wrap: What happened after the In The City reunion tapingSeveral hours later, the first-ever In The City reunion was officially in the books. Amanda and Kyle at the In the City Season 1 Reunion.