Come to find out, this little fella in disguise was actually a moth called a Beautiful Wood Nymph. Kind of a misnomer if you ask me since it looks pretty gross, but there is a reason it looks like bird poop. Here is a short video of a Beautiful Wood Nymph perched on some wood. This moth can be found, "across eastern North America, from Nova Scotia on down to Florida and west into Texas" including right here in Kentucky. Have you ever encountered a Beautiful Wood Nymph?