The refrain is familiar: “Why defend Kimmel if you didn’t defend Gina Carano, Roseanne, or Trump?”But here’s the thing. Gina Carano compared being a Republican to being Jewish in Nazi Germany. One user explained how they cancelled Disney+ over Carano, then roped in friends to do the same:I canceled Disney+ when they fired Gina Carano. "pic.twitter.com/g1cj9Bdpji — Eric Daugherty (@EricLDaugh) September 18, 2025Predictably, detractors rushed to mock them:Didn't see this for Gina Carano or Johnny Depp. Let’s stop pretending it’s about free speechFrom Carano to Kimmel, cancel culture outrage always plays the same game.