Why New York City Dominates the Global Top 50 Pizza ListOnce you're in the city, the ranking doesn't stop at one address. Add it all up, and New York City alone claims eleven spots among the best pizzerias in the United States. The same Italian judges ranked Jay's number seven, and what pushed it that high was the crust. Get our free mobile appPizzeria Florian: The Small-Town NY Spot That Catered a Celebrity WeddingJay Langfelder and Amanda Jones own a spot called Pizzeria Florian, tucked into the small, charming village of East Aurora. The judges ranked Pizzeria Florian fortieth, praising the cozy atmosphere and the kind of creative menu that turns a simple pie into a conversation piece.